EIGHT women have filed an ethics complaint against Senator Vicente Sotto III for making a joke that disparaged single women during the confirmation hearings of Social Welfare and Development Secretary Judy Taguiwalo.
In response to Sotto’s question during the hearing, Taguiwalo said she was a single mother of two, which led the senator to say that on the street, she would have been called “na-ano lang”—a crude reference to women who had had sex then been left unmarried.
In the wake of an angry backlash, Sotto—a one-time comedian and TV host—apologized, saying his critics apparently did not get the joke.
He also dismissed criticism for his personal question, saying that “anything under the sun” can be asked in confirmation hearings.
Taguiwalo said he accepted Sotto’s apology, but has declined to speak of the incident again.
The eight complainants, from various women’s groups, asked the Senate committee on ethics and decorum to sanction Sotto in a manner “commensurate to the insult he made to solo mothers, and by implication, to women, all over the Philippines.”
They also wanted the senator to inhibit himself as chairman of the committee that will handle the case.
In response, Sotto said he will file a leave of absence as committee chairman while the complaint is being heard.
Aside from Sotto, the complainants said other CA members should also be reprimanded for “failing to comment or correct” him during the hearing.
They also wanted the Senate to require all its members, including their staff, to undergo gender sensitivity training to be facilitated by the Philippine Commission on Women.
“In the street language, when you have children and you are single, ang tawag doon ay na-ano lang,” the complaint quoted the senator as saying.
The complaint said several people in the room laughed at Sotto’s remarks while Taguiwalo “merely pursed her lips.”
Sotto’s comment showed that he viewed single or solo mothers as “less than others; demeaning and disparaging women in the same position and making them easy targets of jokes and ridicules.”
“He epitomizes the segment of the misogynist and macho sector of society that considers women, who are without men as less of value,” the complaint said.
“His language normalized the patriarchal view that men has sexual privilege over women, and trivialized abandonment of responsibility over children. He showed his utter insensitivity and disregard to the hard work, strong will and determination of mothers, who raise children on their own,” it added.
As a legislator, Sotto has also undermined national policies that have underpinned laws such as The Solo Parents Welfare Act and the Magna Carta of Women.
It was also “alarming” that not a single member of the CA “corrected or commented” on Sotto’s remark, the complaint said.
“There is violence and discrimination against women not just through the commission on [an] act but also through an omission of an act,” it said.
“When the members of the Committee on Appointments remained silent, it is tantamount to tolerating the sexist acts and remarks of Senator Sotto toward Judy Taguiwalo.”
“Worse, the comment solicited laughter, making those who did so as insulting and downgrading as the one who uttered the insults,” it further said.
The complaint also cited other “ethical infractions” allegedly committed by Sotto such as his remark in a noon time show show in July 2016 where the latter supposedly shamed a “sexually assaulted woman” by saying “kababae mong tao, pa shot-shot ka pa.”
The eight complainants are Jean Enriquez of the Coalition Against Trafficking in Women-Asia Pacific and the World March of Women (WMW)-Pilipinas, Clarissa Militante of the WMW, Amparo Miciano Sykioco of the Pambansang Koalisyon ng Kababaihan sa Kanayunan, Judith Pamela Afan Pasimio of Lilak or the Purple Action for Indigenous Womens’ Rights, Judy Ann Chan Miranda of the Partido ng Manggagawa, Ana Maria Nemenzo of the Woman Health Philippines, Josua Mata of the Sentro ng Manggagawa ng Pilipinas, and Myrna Hernandez Jimenez.
